Actually, I think Silver was the ONLY thing right with the game.
I've seen how all these people just hate Silver for some reason when he was the one and only character in the game who was any good. (They kind of twisted everyone else in the game but Blaze. Shadow? Now, Sonic's more mysterious than him.) And Silver ROCKED!
Yeah, at first he was really hard to use. Those telekinetic powers where hard to control at first. But when I got better control of them, I kept playing as Silver in 2-P Battle Mode. The only problem is that they can easily block your eyesight.
But, then, Silver's friend, Blaze, on the other hand... Worst attacks/controls ever.
Sonic and the Black Knight
I agree. Also that the graphics where goo. But if you meant to say "good", I don't think they where good. Just smooth and detailed. But they look really dirty. Especially for the characters. Primarily Shadow. And the facial expressions where terrible. Again, primarily for Shadow. Example: The scene right after he and Silver fight and then they go into the past. Plus, how did he know all that? No one ever told him. Plus, he wasn't even awaken, yet!